Let's Talk
I'm ready to meet with someone
Step 2 of 2

Tell us about yourself.

Please complete all fields.
Back
Programs that create passionate customers. Built by marketers, for marketers.
Do much more with your data. Find, win, and retain the customers you want.
Fine-tune your strategy, streamline execution, and get more engagement.
Warehousing and shipping that’s smarter and more secure.
More personal than you thought possible. Printed and delivered with precision.
On-brand sign production and fulfillment, at the speed of retail.
Customize, order, print, and ship. From anywhere, any time.
Turn shoppers into buyers. And buyers into champions.
Tantalize fans and new diners alike with marketing and menus that sizzle.
Complete services for direct to consumer selling: marketing, packaging, and shipping.
Personalized marketing and kitting in a highly secure environment. MICR too!
Streamline your direct-marketing programs – for every franchisee.
Personalized member communications, secure and HIPAA compliant.
It’s all about relationships – and donations. We’ll help you grow both.
Deliver the right message to voters at the right time. End-to-end DM services.
See how we’ve helped clients in healthcare, fashion, franchise and more.
Smarter loyalty helped this icon engage customers and exceed goals.
Our digital storefront supplied POS signs and more for this pharma giant.
Scalable, better quality marketing at lower costs? See how we did it.
Data analysis drives higher customer acquisition for this fashion icon.
Our SOS system provided cheaper, faster, better POS fulfillment.
We helped them launch a direct to consumer operation — and drive sales.
See how we helped RL achieve a 60% jump in flagship opening-week sales.
Our refreshed loyalty program helped them double members — annually.
Metric analysis and a cleaner list drove huge campaign lifts.
200% Increase in speed to market
See how we helped DSW save $250,000
It’s simple: We get personal. Here’s what that means.
We love people who bring energy and curiosity to work. Sound like you?
When you care this much, it shows in the work.
Stay up to date with marketing insights and tips about how to acquire and grow the customers you want.
From eBooks to interactive tools, we’ve got the CRM & analytics, loyalty, and direct mail resources you’re looking for.
Learn how Direct Mail is used to connect with clients at every stage of the customer journey, whether you're building awareness or encouraging long-term loyalty.
Step 1 of 2

What interests you most?

Select all that apply.
Options
Next
Back

Holiday Loyalty: How Exclusive Rewards Drive Engagement and Sales

by
Baesman
tags Email & SMS Loyalty Programs CRM & Analytics

The holidays are a make-or-break season for brands. With inboxes full, shoppers stretched thin, and competitors everywhere contending for attention, loyalty programs need to step up. When done right, loyalty-exclusive offers don’t just boost short-term sales, they deepen engagement, strengthen emotional connection, and deliver lifetime value.

Here’s how brands can structure loyalty-exclusive offers like early access, bonus points, or VIP rewards to maximize engagement and sales over the holidays.

Why Holiday Loyalty Exclusives Are Crucial

Your loyalty members are already primed to shop with you during the holidays. They’ve shown interest, purchased before, and trust your brand. Instead of treating them the same as every other shopper, exclusive rewards create recognition and deepen their connection with you.

Think beyond standard discounts. Offers like early access to promotions, bonus points, or VIP-only bundles don’t just drive sales they create a sense of status and belonging that strengthens the customer-brand relationship.

Key Types of Loyalty-Exclusive Offers to Use

Offer Type Why It Works Holiday Season Best Practices
Early Access to sales, new product drops Builds anticipation; lets your top members shop before inventory scarcity or price markdowns kick in. Time-limit early access; send segmented invites; use tiering so higher tiers get earlier or better access.
Bonus Points / Point Multipliers Encourages stronger spend, repeat purchase; gives more value back during high-cost season. Set clear time windows (e.g. “double points weekends”); align with promotional calendar; cap or tier to avoid runaway cost.
VIP-Only Bundles or Products Gives something unique; elevates perceived value; can feel like a collector’s or limited edition. Curate these bundles; highlight scarcity or “only for members”; ensure they are genuinely differentiated.
Free Perks / Services (free shipping, gift wrap, express checkout etc.) Addresses holiday pain points (last-minute gifts, shipping delays) which can often be deal-breakers. Make the perk obvious; ensure logistical capacity; consider “free shipping for members during X days.”
Experiences & Events (member-only shopping hours, virtual or in-person events) Emotional connection; builds community; often memorable & shareable.

Promote ahead of time; tie in extra incentives (discounts or surprise rewards during event); make events feel exclusive.

How to Structure These Offers for Maximum Impact

  • Segment & target
    Don’t treat all loyalty members the same. Identify:
      • Top-tier / high lifetime value
      • Lapsed or low-engagement members
      • New joiners during the season
    Then tailor offers accordingly (e.g. highest-tier gets earliest access, lapsed get re-engagement bonus).

  • Tie into the overall holiday campaign calendar
    Plan in phases: pre-holiday (teaser/early), peak shopping (Black Friday / Cyber Monday etc.), last-minute & post-holiday. Schedule loyalty exclusives to align (and possibly lead) these phases.

  • Use urgency & scarcity
    Limits (e.g. “first 100 customers”, “ends midnight”), exclusivity (“members only”, “VIP”), or quantity caps emphasize urgency.

  • Clear, simple communication
    Make the path easy:
      1. Tell them what their tier is, what they’ve already earned.
      2. Show what benefit(s) are available now.
      3. Show how close they are to unlocking more.

  • Multi-channel delivery
    Use every channel you’ve got for loyalty messaging: email, SMS, app push notifications, in-app banners, direct mail, and social. But tailor the approach: send high-priority announcements through more direct and personal channels, while using broader channels to build awareness and excitement.

  • Reward early engagement & behavior, not just spend
    Example: bonus points for browsing / adding to wishlist, referrals, social engagement especially handy for members who might not yet be big spenders.

Pitfalls to Avoid

  • Overpromising / underdelivering exclusive access

  • Too many overlapping offers (confusion)

  • Making benefits too complex to understand (members need clarity)

  • Failing to ensure logistics keep up (shipping, inventory, customer service)

  • Neglecting lower-tier or less active members (they can become future high value if nurtured properly)

Measuring Success & Adjusting

  • Key Metrics to Track
      - Redemption rate of exclusive offers
      - Increase in spend / average order value (AOV) among loyalty members vs non-members
      -  Engagement metrics: open/click rates on loyalty-specific emails; app use; number of visits / purchases during exclusive windows
      - Retention / re-purchase after holiday season

  • Use real-time data to optimize
    If a bonus points campaign isn’t driving enough lift, tweak messaging or extend access. If early access inventory is moving too slowly, adjust or promote more heavily.

Holiday Loyalty Program Action Plan: Steps Brands Should Take Now

To maximize holiday sales and strengthen long-term customer retention, brands should take a strategic approach to loyalty-exclusive rewards. Here’s a step-by-step action plan to prepare your holiday loyalty program for success:

  1. Audit current loyalty program tiers, perks, benefits: what’s working & what’s not.

  2. Map out holiday campaign calendar, overlaying loyalty-exclusive offers (early access, bonus points, “VIP days”) at strategic moments.

  3. Segment your loyalty base, identify which groups deserve what kinds of exclusives.

  4. Design the creative & rewards (bundles, free perks, events) that feel truly special—not just “a small discount.”

  5. Prepare communication flow: drip emails, push/SMS, app banners, maybe in-store if applicable.

  6. Set up measurement & feedback loops to monitor performance, test variants, ensure fulfillment & customer satisfaction.

New call-to-action

Personalization Is Key

To maximize engagement, loyalty messaging should go beyond one-size-fits-all promotions. Use your marketing channels like email, SMS, app, and direct mail, to deliver personalized content that highlights:

  • The member’s tier or status

  • Benefits they can unlock or redeem this season

  • Featured products and services curated just for them

When customers clearly understand their value in your program and see rewards tied to their behavior, they’re more motivated to act.

Building Loyalty That Lasts Beyond the Holidays

Loyalty-exclusive offers during the holidays are more than just nice add-ons—they’re strategic tools. When integrated well into your holiday promotional strategy, they:

  • Give your best customers meaningful recognition

  • Encourage earlier, larger purchases

  • Enhance emotional connection and lifetime value

  • Distinguish your brand in a crowded field

If you design holiday exclusives that are clear, valuable, and genuinely differentiated, you’ll not only win sales during the busiest season you’ll reinforce loyalty that pays off long after the last gift is unwrapped.

At Baesman, we help brands bring these strategies to life by building and managing loyalty programs, creating personalized campaigns, and delivering multi-channel communications that keep customers engaged all year long. Whether you need support with segmentation, campaign execution, or loyalty program design, our team can ensure your holiday strategy drives both sales and retention.

Download the Customer Loyalty Lifecycle eBook

 
by
Baesman
tags
View all articles